Metal vs. Shingle Roofs: A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners

Home Services Buying Guide

A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners

A close up of a metal roof with a white background

For many homeowners, the thought of replacing a roof brings to mind traditional asphalt shingles. However, a growing number are now considering metal roofing, a durable and increasingly popular alternative. This guide will explore the key differences between metal and shingled roofs, essential considerations for making the switch, cost expectations, and how to find the right contractor for your project.


Understanding the Differences: Metal vs. Traditional Shingles


While both metal and asphalt shingle roofs serve the primary function of protecting your home, they differ significantly in their composition, performance, and long-term value.


Asphalt Shingle Roofs:

  • Composition: Typically made from a fiberglass mat coated with asphalt and ceramic granules.
  • Cost (Initial): Generally the most affordable option upfront, ranging from $3 to $8 per square foot installed.
  • Lifespan: 15-30 years, with higher-quality architectural or luxury shingles lasting longer.
  • Durability: Susceptible to damage from high winds, hail, and extreme temperature fluctuations (cracking, curling, granule loss).
  • Maintenance: Requires periodic inspections for damaged or missing shingles, and can be prone to moss and algae growth. Repairs are generally easier and less costly for individual shingles.
  • Energy Efficiency: Tends to absorb heat from the sun, leading to higher cooling costs in warmer climates.
  • Appearance: Available in a wide variety of colors and styles, mimicking other materials like wood shakes or slate.
  • Environmental Impact: Less environmentally friendly, as they are petroleum-based and often end up in landfills.


Metal Roofs:

  • Composition: Can be made from various metals like steel (galvanized or Galvalume), aluminum, copper, or zinc, available in panels (e.g., standing seam, corrugated) or shingles designed to mimic traditional roofing.
  • Cost (Initial): Higher upfront investment, typically ranging from $8 to $30+ per square foot installed, depending on the type of metal and style. Copper and zinc are at the higher end of this spectrum.
  • Lifespan: Significantly longer, often 40-70 years or more, with some copper roofs lasting over 100 years.
  • Durability: Highly resistant to wind (up to 120 mph with proper installation), hail (some have high impact ratings), fire, rot, and pests. Can be prone to denting from heavy objects like falling tree branches, depending on the metal's thickness.
  • Maintenance: Low maintenance, requiring periodic inspections and cleaning.
  • Energy Efficiency: Excellent at reflecting sunlight, which can significantly reduce cooling costs, particularly in hot climates. Some have reflective pigments to further enhance this.
  • Appearance: Offers a wide range of styles, colors, and finishes, including options that convincingly replicate the look of asphalt shingles, slate, or wood shakes.
  • Environmental Impact: Highly recyclable and often made from recycled content, making them a more sustainable choice.
  • Noise: Can be noisier during heavy rain or hail, though proper insulation and underlayment can mitigate this.


What to Consider When Replacing a Shingled Roof with a Metal Roof


Transitioning from shingles to metal is a significant home improvement project. Here are crucial factors to consider:


  1. Roof Decking Condition: When replacing a shingle roof with a metal one, it's highly recommended to tear off the old shingles down to the roof decking. This allows your contractor to inspect the decking for any rot, damage, or structural issues. Installing metal over existing shingles can hide underlying problems, add excessive weight (potentially stressing compromised decking), and make future leak detection and repair much harder. While some circumstances might allow for a "roof-over" to save on labor and disposal costs, it's generally not advised for long-term integrity.
  2. Structural Integrity: Metal roofs, while surprisingly lightweight for their durability, still add weight. Ensure your roof's existing structure can adequately support the new metal system, especially if you're layering it over old shingles (which is generally discouraged).
  3. Local Building Codes and Permits: Always check with your local building authority for required permits and specific regulations regarding metal roof installations. Some jurisdictions have restrictions on layering roofing materials.
  4. Ventilation: Proper attic ventilation is critical for any roof, and especially with a metal roof, to prevent moisture buildup beneath the roofing layers. Discuss ventilation strategies with your contractor.
  5. Noise Mitigation: While modern metal roofs often incorporate noise-dampening layers, discuss potential noise from rain and hail with your contractor. Additional insulation can help reduce this.
  6. Style and Aesthetics: Metal roofing offers diverse styles. Decide if you prefer the modern look of standing seam panels, the traditional appearance of metal shingles, or another option that complements your home's architecture.
  7. Long-Term Investment vs. Upfront Cost: While the initial cost is higher, factor in the extended lifespan, potential energy savings, and higher resale value that a metal roof can offer. It's an investment that can pay off over decades.


Cost Expectations


The cost of replacing a shingled roof with a metal roof can vary significantly based on:


  • Type of Metal: Steel and aluminum are generally more affordable than copper or zinc.
  • Roof Style: Corrugated panels might be less expensive than standing seam or metal shingles.
  • Roof Size and Complexity: Larger or more intricate roofs with multiple angles, dormers, or chimneys will incur higher labor and material costs.
  • Location: Labor rates and material availability vary by region.
  • Old Roof Removal: The cost to remove and dispose of your old shingle roof (typically $1,000-$3,000) should be factored in, as this is usually recommended.
  • Underlayment and Additional Materials: High-quality underlayment and other necessary components add to the overall cost.


General Cost Ranges (per square foot, including materials and labor):


  • Asphalt Shingle Roof: $3 - $8
  • Metal Roof (overall average): $8 - $30+
  • Steel (Galvalume/Galvanized): $4 - $10
  • Aluminum: $6 - $13
  • Metal Shingles: $6 - $12
  • Standing Seam: $7 - $15
  • Copper: $15 - $30


For a typical 2,000-square-foot home, the total cost for a metal roof replacement could range from $10,000 to $20,000 for mid-range materials like steel or aluminum, potentially reaching $30,000 or more for high-end materials or complex installations.


How to Hire a Contractor


Hiring a reputable and experienced contractor is paramount for a successful metal roof installation. Here's a step-by-step guide:


  1. Seek Referrals: Ask friends, family, and neighbors who have recently had metal roofs installed for recommendations. Look for recent roofing projects in your area and inquire about the contractors used.
  2. Verify Licensing and Insurance:
  • License: Ensure the contractor is properly licensed in your state and local municipality. Verify the license is current and has no violations.
  • Insurance: Insist on proof of both general liability insurance (covers damage to your property) and worker's compensation insurance (covers injuries to their employees on your property). Get certificates directly from the insurance provider, with your name and address listed as an additional insured.
  1. Check Experience with Metal Roofs: Metal roof installation requires specialized skills and tools. Confirm the contractor has extensive experience specifically with metal roofing systems, ideally at least three years. Ask for a portfolio of their completed metal roofing projects.
  2. Request Detailed Written Proposals: Obtain quotes from at least three different contractors. The proposal should be comprehensive, detailing:
  • Scope of work (including old roof removal)
  • Specific materials to be used (type of metal, gauge, finish, underlayment, fasteners, flashing)
  • Installation methods and specifications
  • Start and estimated completion dates
  • Total cost, including labor, materials, permits, and waste disposal.
  • Payment schedule.
  1. Review References and Online Reviews: Contact client references provided by the contractor to learn about their experience. Check online reviews on platforms like Google My Business, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Look for consistent positive feedback and how the contractor addresses any negative reviews.
  2. Inquire About Warranties: Understand both the contractor's workmanship warranty and the manufacturer's material warranty.
  • Workmanship Warranty: Should cover issues related to the installation, often for a period of 2-5 years.
  • Manufacturer's Warranty: Covers the materials themselves (e.g., paint finish, structural integrity) and can range from 20-50+ years. Understand any conditions that might void these warranties.
  1. Discuss Subcontractors: Ask if they use subcontractors. If so, request their information, proof of insurance, and references as well. It's often preferable to work with a company that uses its own trained employees.
  2. Avoid High-Pressure Sales Tactics: A reputable contractor will provide clear information and allow you time to make an informed decision without pressure.
  3. Don't Prioritize Price Alone: While cost is a factor, the expertise, reputation, and quality of work are more important for a long-lasting and effective metal roof. A suspiciously low bid could indicate corner-cutting.


By carefully considering these aspects, you can confidently navigate the process of replacing your shingled roof with a durable, energy-efficient, and long-lasting metal roof, enhancing the value and protection of your home for decades to come.



Sources and Links:



Share